2023 Honda Pilot Key Fob: Complete Options Comparison

A comprehensive comparison of all key fob replacement options for the 2023 Honda Pilot. Make an informed decision based on cost, quality, and convenience.

Quick Decision Summary

Best Value

Aftermarket + Locksmith

Purchase compatible aftermarket key online, have local locksmith program

Typical: $80–$200

Best for: Budget-conscious, non-luxury vehicles

Most Reliable

Dealership OEM

Factory key from authorized Honda dealer

Typical: $200–$500+

Best for: Warranty concerns, luxury/newer vehicles

Most Convenient

Mobile Locksmith

Full service at your location

Typical: $150–$350

Best for: Emergencies, no transportation available

Detailed Option Comparison

Factor Dealership Locksmith Online + Programming
Typical Cost $200–$500+ $150–$350 $80–$200
Parts Quality OEM (Original) OEM or Aftermarket Aftermarket (varies)
Warranty Full manufacturer warranty Locksmith warranty (varies) Limited or none
Convenience May require appointment Often mobile service Requires research
Wait Time Same day to 1 week Usually same day Shipping + scheduling
Risk Level Low Low-Medium Medium

Pros and Cons by Option

Dealership (OEM)

✓ Pros

  • Guaranteed compatibility
  • Full warranty coverage
  • Professional programming
  • No compatibility research needed

✗ Cons

  • Highest cost option
  • May require appointment
  • Vehicle must be present
  • Potential upselling

Automotive Locksmith

✓ Pros

  • Often 20-40% cheaper than dealer
  • Mobile service available
  • Usually same-day service
  • Can often use OEM parts

✗ Cons

  • Quality varies by provider
  • May use aftermarket parts
  • Not all can program all vehicles
  • Scams exist—verify credentials

Online Purchase + Local Programming

✓ Pros

  • Lowest hardware cost
  • Wide selection available
  • Can comparison shop
  • Good for spare keys

✗ Cons

  • Compatibility risk
  • Need to find programming service
  • No returns on cut/programmed keys
  • Quality varies significantly

When to Choose Each Option

Choose Dealership When:

  • Your vehicle is under warranty
  • You have a luxury or high-security vehicle
  • You want guaranteed OEM quality
  • Cost is not the primary concern

Choose Locksmith When:

  • You need same-day service
  • You want a balance of cost and quality
  • Mobile service is important
  • Your vehicle is out of warranty

Choose Online When:

  • You're getting a spare (not emergency)
  • Budget is the priority
  • You're comfortable with research
  • You have time to wait for shipping

Risk Assessment

Low Risk

Dealership Purchase

Minimal risk of compatibility issues or quality problems

Medium Risk

Reputable Locksmith

Verify credentials, check reviews, confirm equipment compatibility

Medium-High Risk

Aftermarket Online

Research seller, verify compatibility, understand return policy

Related Information